Strangers by Belle Burden: A Book Review

by kjgurney
0 comments
Strangers by Belle Burden

At a glance

Strangers

Belle Burden

Genre Memoir
Format Paperback, 237 pages
Point of view First person
Tense Past tense
Source Local library
Did I finish it? Yes, in 3 days
My rating 3.5 / 5
Read if you liked The marriage unravelling and midlife reckoning of Miranda July's All Fours, without the surrealism.
Would I recommend it? ― Maybe

Belle Burden’s debut memoir arrived on the back of a New York Times Modern Love essay and hit the bestseller list. Whether the book lives up to its own premise is a more complicated question.

Synopsis

In March 2020, days after the world locked down, Belle Burden’s husband of twenty years told her he was leaving. They were quarantining together at their Martha’s Vineyard home when he announced the marriage was over. Strangers is the account of what came before and next: the unravelling of a life she had built in good faith, and her attempt to understand how she had been living alongside someone she didn’t really know.

My review

Belle Burden is a Harvard and NYU-trained immigration lawyer, the granddaughter of Babe Paley, and a product of a certain kind of New York life. She wrote a Modern Love essay about her divorce; it was published in the New York Times, and became this book. Gwyneth Paltrow is attached to star in the Netflix adaptation, and to me, the casting is perfect. If you can picture the person Gwyneth Paltrow would convincingly play, you have a reasonable picture of Belle Burden in her memoir.

The memoir unfolds largely during Covid, which is where I imagine it loses some readers before it even starts. For those of us who lived through lockdown, being asked to relive it is a lot. The face masks, the closed playgrounds, the four walls of our increasingly suffocating homes. Much like references to old popular songs, or TV Shows (both of which Burden also includes), it dates the book, making it almost a little ‘cringe’.

The privilege question is harder to write about, because Burden is a real person and this is her real grief. She suffered. That’s true. But the specific shape of her suffering, worrying about whether she’d have to sell the Martha’s Vineyard house with the pool, whether she could keep the spacious Manhattan apartment, whether the financial decisions she’d naively ceded to her husband would catch up with her, exists at a remove that most readers simply cannot access. As a millennial woman, I have grown up with one instruction baked in: don’t let a man be your financial plan. A marriage certificate is not a guarantee. Watching a woman of Burden’s education and resources make choices against this advice made me want to scream at the book.

The book reads linearly. This happened, then this happened, then this happened. Burden does open with an inciting incident before rewinding to the beginning, so there is an arc. But it’s a factual account at heart, and it moves like one. Reading very much as nonfiction. Throughout, she returns to a family of ospreys nesting near the house, using them as a kind of emotional counterpoint. I found myself skimming these passages. They feel like a gear-change into literary writing, and they slow rather than deepen the story.

What I liked

It’s short and easy to read. Burden’s account of the marriage’s immediate aftermath is sharp. The legal sections, where she navigates the financial consequences of having trusted someone she shouldn’t have, are the most compelling in the book.

What I didn’t

The Covid setting and pop culture references age it. The privilege gap is unrelatable and led me, as the reader, to lose some of my sympathy for what does, genuinely seem, to be a truly traumatic experience. 

Final verdict

Strangers is a quick, readable memoir from a woman working through a genuine betrayal. If the privilege gap is a barrier from page one, it probably won’t close by the end. Read a chapter or two from the library before you commit.

Format Platform Cost Notes
Physical Booktopia Paid Paperback available. Ships Australia-wide.
Library Your local library BorrowBox Libby Free Free with a library card. Check BorrowBox and Libby for digital borrowing. Availability varies by council.
eBook Kindle / Apple Books / Kobo Paid 237 pages. A quick read, well suited to a screen.
Audiobook Audible Libby (library) Paid / Free* Narrated by the author. Runs 7 hrs 6 mins. Fits within the Spotify Premium free monthly listening allowance. Free via Libby if your library has it.

* Free with a valid Australian library card where available through your library's Libby partnership.

Strangers: a Memoir of Marriage

Belle Burden’s husband of twenty years left her and their children in the first week of lockdown. What followed became a New York Times essay, then a memoir, then a Netflix deal. The book is quick, honest, and set in a world or priveledge most of us will never inhabit.

URL: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/231108670-strangers

Author: Belle Burden

Editor's Rating:
3.5

You may also like

Leave a Comment